The concept of ‘Illinibucks’ is an interesting one, because basically
it looks at how students value time and the differences between those
valuations. By permitting students to jump to the front of the lines of things
very important to them, the university is allowing them to reveal how they
value their time and what is most important to them. This, in turn, means that students
will be comfortable with waiting for things that aren’t as important to them. By
putting the power and choice in the students’ hands would greatly increase
student happiness at no cost to the university.
Once the concept of Illinibucks is established a few
questions arise. First, how are the Illinibucks allocated, are they distributed
every week or are they given out at the beginning of the semester? To answer
this all one must do is look at the original purpose of Illinibucks: to provide
ease and increased happiness to students. In order to do maximize students’ happiness,
one would think students’ should have the most options, and therefore giving out
a lump of Illinibucks at the beginning of the semester is a superior strategy.
Another question that arises is pricing of Illinibucks. If the price is too low
then there is an overabundance of Illinibucks and the point of Illinibucks is
completely ruined because instead of students using them on things that are important
to them they use them, they will be used flippantly. While if the price is too
high, Illinibucks just will not be bought or used. Similarly to price, the
quantity of Illinibucks distributed is also a big deal for similar reasons. If
the quantity is too high frivolous use will ensue, while if the quantity is too
low Illinibucks will become very valuable but potentially costly. At very high
prices or low quantities there could potential for hoarding of Illinibucks to
begin, or, at the very least, there is possible that students will be disincentivized
to do things that involve Illinibucks because they don’t see it as being worth
an Illinibuck. For these reasons the price and quantity of Illinibucks has to
be just right or the entire idea behind them is ruined.
When I think about how I would spend my Illinibucks, it
becomes fairly clear why they are not a real thing. First, let me explain the
two ways I see Illinibucks being useful: One, the convenience of skipping the line
at Starbucks to get your coffee a couple minutes faster, versus two, the
convenience of registering for classes early, without worrying about them being
closed. One has the instant gratification and time from not waiting in line, the
other is the practicality and ease of mind of being able to not worry about
classes. In my experience, in all of my time on campus, the amount of time I
have spent waiting in any one line is not enough to warrant the use of an
Illinibuck. What I feel I would use my Illinibucks on would be class
registration, and this is where I feel the problem comes in. I have a feeling
many people on campus feel the same way as me as far as what would be the most
efficient and useful way to use their Illinibucks. If this is the case then the
entire purpose behind Illinibucks in this scenario is gone, because, like when I
was talking about the pricing and quantity of Illinibucks, too many people use
their Illinibucks on the same thing. Every student can’t be the first person to
sign up for classes, and when students are asked to prioritize whether they
want to wait in line a bit less or sign up for classes first, a majority will
pick class registration and the whole Illinibuck system falls apart.
Let me take on your last paragraph. It is true that everyone can't be the first in line. But that doesn't mean time pricing (first come first served) is the best way to allocate a resource. So, in particular, if a senior as an elective gets into a class that would be a requirement for a sophomore who now can't get into the class, it might be efficient to bump the senior and let the sophomore in. Might that happen with an Illinibucks approach?
ReplyDeleteHere is where it can work as well as where it can't. If there are many lines that students must wait in to get access and if the Illinibucks lets the students to to the head of a couple of those lines but not too many, then the students can prioritize which lines are most important to them and that can improve efficiency. If there is just one long line to access everything, then somebody going earlier makes everyone further back go later. That puts the whole thing into a zero sum context and then nothing improves.